deathtokoalas
this stuff is so absurdly over-rated. back in the day, bands like coil and autechre and nurse with wound actually wrote compositions. this is just a simple loop running in cubase through a stack of vst instruments.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rIraStrVIGA
(this is a forgotten oneohtrix point never song)
i mean, even eno mostly wrote songs that went somewhere. this is just wallpaper.
(deleted post)
deathtokoalas
i don't think there's much of an evolution in expression at all, there's just a collapse in structure. this isn't remotely sonically innovative.
and if this was actually played rather than sequenced, i'm going to laugh for the next week. but, i don't think it's a juno. that's not analog synth work, it's very digital. and i don't think it's played either, to be honest. it's too locked. so, maybe they used a digital sequencer to drive a d-50 instead of cubase to drive a vst sound engine. it's the same thing....,
(deleted post)
deathtokoalas
it's not a question of writing things down conventionally, although it helps if you can. i happen to know that neither booth nor brown had any understanding of music theory when they started (although i'd argue that quite a bit is audible over oversteps, so they must have picked up a few books), so it wasn't an option for them. rdj, on the other hand, has always leaned rather heavily in that direction.
it's just more of a question of writing pieces that unfold in a complex manner. so, you're asking the wrong question. a better question is if autechre would have ever released anything that is this static in it's approach, and the answer is that they wouldn't have (excluding, perhaps, a few pieces on amber). autechre's stuff tends to unfold and morph rather dramatically. that's all i meant by using the term "composition" - something that is written, however it happens to
be written, rather than something that is tossed together haphazardly.
i just listened to it again and i suspect it might actually be generative music. it was probably made in koan or something.
regardless, it's not that it's a bad loop. it's a decent base to build something on. i've done this myself more than once. and, even as a segue, it has the potential to provide a little levity in the middle of a record. but,
all his stuff is like this.
even that's not such a thing to get irritated by. it's just the fact that they pulled him out of a significant pool of similar artists that are doing something more interesting.
it's the visuals. he's used them to leap frog over his more talented contemporaries. it's a gimmick. and that bugs me....
i mean, scores by cage or xenakis or whatever tend not to feature a lot of conventional musical ideas, but that doesn't mean they're not compositions. and, i doubt autechre wrote much down, unless you count the programming, but the way they built up tracks, and the attention they spent on microdetails, is very compositional in nature.
you just don't hear that in this guy's work.